Could Britain become a disunited kingdom?

Back in 2014, Scotland took a vote on whether to stay in the United Kingdom (known to friends and family as plain old Britain) and stay got 55% of the vote. Leave got the other 45%. There was no third choice, making the numbers line up neatly. The turnout was high–84.5%. By way of comparison, the percentage of people voting to leave the European Union (Brexit) was 52%, with 48% voting to stay, again with no third choice. The turnout was 72%.

Did either of those votes close the conversation? 

Of course not. The possibility of a British re-entry to the EU (Brentry?) is back in the headlines and so is the possibility of breaking up the UK. 

We live in confusing times, and even when the arguments come back around, the forms they take are different. 

 

irrelevant photo: a thistle

How much of a chance does a breakup have?

At the moment, it’s all noise. If you live in the UK, it’s not time to pack up and move to the nation whose citizenship you prefer. We’re still all one big, squabbling country, and if you drive from one nation to the next, you’ll notice a sign or two to mark the change, but nothing more. Unless your drive involves Northern Ireland, in which case you’ll notice salt water. Lots of salt water. 

But noise is often the first form political change takes, so it’s worth listening to. 

Before I go on, though, I should draw a couple of arrows pointing to the word nations that dropped in a couple of paragraphs back, because we’re not talking about countries leaving the UK. The UK is the country. It has an army, a foreign policy, all the things that mark it as a country. Wales is a nation within that country. So are Scotland and Northern Ireland. But the country has certain powers over the nations because it’s bigger and it wrote the rules.

All three nations have their own parliaments, and in recent years British governments have handed increasing amounts of power to them. That leaves England–the poker player with the biggest pile of chips–in the weird position of not having an English parliament. It’s governed by the British one, again because England wrote the rules. That was a long time ago but they still hold, even if they don’t fit as well as they used to. 

 

The game pieces here . . .

. . . are Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. 

Wales has two pro-indepence parties: Plaid Cymru (left to center-left, politically speaking) and the smaller Gwlad (center right). Unwrap those two for Christmas and they spell out a message about nationalism: it comes in more than one flavor and solving the independence problem leaves you nose to eyeball with all the problems that divide left and right. Sometimes it leaves you nose to eyeball with your former allies. 

Sometimes it leads a person to stuff too many images into a single paragraph.

It’s off the topic, but Wikipedia tells me that Gwlad changed its name in 2019 to Gwlad Gwlad, which is Welsh for nation, nation–or in another translation, land, land. It’s from the Welsh national anthem, or as some sites have it, the de facto national anthem, since it never got official sanction, in spite of the Welsh parliament’s increased powers. Follow the link for some half a dozen versions of the song. The anthem may be unofficial, but one version isn’t enough.

Plaid Cymru is the largest party in the Senedd (the Welsh parliament) but doesn’t hold a majority.

Scotland has multiple independence parties, The Scottish National Party is the largest. It’s center-left and wants an independent Scotland, which would then rejoin the European Union, neatly linking the middle of this post to the beginning. (Thanks, folks.) The Independence for Scotland Party mentions social justice, so let’s guess it’s at least vaguely leftish. The Greens aren’t primarily a nationalist party but do support independence. Then there’s the Alliance to Liberate Scotland, whose goal is to coordinate independence candidates. It calls itself a single-issue movement, which translates to Let’s all get together and achieve this one goal and after that we can fight with each other. This is so achievable that the ISP left the alliance last March. 

We’ll skip the Alba Party, which ran out of money and pulled down the shutters.  

The SNP is the largest party in Holyrood–the Scottish parliament–but doesn’t hold a  majority. 

Think those two were complicated? Take a look at Northern Ireland. I won’t even pretend to sort out all the players there. If you want a list of the parties, follow the yellow brick link. 

Sorry–it’s blue, not yellow. And not brick.

Briefly (and to my surprise), a few minor parties want independence but not reunification with Ireland, but let’s focus on the Catholic parties seeking not just independence from the UK but reunification with the Irish Republic,. They’re the more serious political force. Northern Ireland’s first minister and deputy first minister are determined by a power-sharing agreement, and at the moment, Sinn Fein–a nationalist group that wants reunification–is driving the car. 

 

Breaking up the union

Now that we’ve labeled the game pieces and the cat’s pushed a few under the couch, it’s time to explain that the three national leaders got together at a September 2026 summit in Cardiff and signed a couple of agreements saying their nations had the right to decide their own futures. 

How significant is that? Well, neither document changes anything immediately, but you can’t write them off as mere noise. Or if you do, you’ll have to admit that they at least turn up the volume. 

The politics of gesture.

One document was signed by the three as party leaders, not as first ministers. It says the three nations have the right to self-determination and that Westminster–that’s shorthand for Britain’s government–has no right to get in their way. 

Before the ink was dry, they ducked behind the curtain and changed into their government costumes to sign the second one, so the content had to be more moderate. Here they talked about the right of citizens to decide their constitutional future “through democratic means. (I’ve plagiarized a phrase or three in explaining all this, so here’s the link crediting the source for both the wording and a fair bit of the information.) 

The problem there is that international law only recognizes people’s right to self-determination if they’re dealing with colonial rule or extreme oppression. Short of that, it doesn’t recognize a region’s right to break away from a state. A history of colonial rule and extreme oppression? Sorry, that doesn’t qualify. 

Britain’s Supreme Court ruled at some point that the Scottish, Northern Irish, and Welsh legislatures aren’t allowed to use their powers to pressure Westminster to break up the union, and the Cardiff agreements are dancing right up to that line but not crossing it. They signed political agreements, not legislation. 

 

So can the three nations become independent? 

You didn’t expect a simple answer to that, did you?

Northern Ireland has a path to independence based on the Good Friday Agreement (1998; you’re welcome). If it looks likely that a majority of citizens in Northern Ireland would vote for reunification with the Republic of Ireland, the Northern Ireland secretary (that’s a British official, in case you’ve gotten lost) has to call a vote–not just in Northern Ireland but also in the Republic. Each of those polls have to be counted up separately and if both of them show a majority for reunification, it’ll happen. If only one does, the deal’s off. 

Will the UK accept that? If we’re betting, I’ll say yes, but it hasn’t happened yet and if it ever does we can’t know who’ll be running the show in Westminster, so I’ll keep my bet small. 

Scotland only got to hold a referendum on independence in 2014 because Westminster, in the person of the then-prime minister David Cameron, thought it was a good idea. (He also thought a referendum on EU membership was a good idea. He won the first bet and lost the second, after which he retreated into political irrelevance.)

Subsequent prime ministers haven’t been inclined to bet on that again.

Wales could, theoretically, also hold a referendum but again only if Westminster agrees, and it hasn’t. The Senedd passed a motion saying Wales has the right to hold a referendum but that’s not the same as actually holding one. Or holding one that both nations recognize as binding.

The underlying problem is that the UK has no rules setting out whether the union’s voluntary and what sort of popular or political demand would force Westminster to put the question to a vote. 

What did you expect from a country with an unwritten constitution?

If all three nations did become countries, nothing I see in the tea leaves indicates that they’d want a monarch or that they could magic up a convincing one if they did. So forget the kingdom part of the disunited kingdom. 

In the midst of all this, you might want to notice that no one talks about England leaving the UK. Back when England wrote the rules, why would it want to? It was acquiring, not joining. But it doesn’t seem to occur to anyone now either. Ask Lord Google, “Will England leave the U.K.” and he and his evil twin Lord AI won’t come up with anything remotely like an answer. The closest thing I found was from AI, which said, “England is the core of the U.K.” 

Would I be stretching a point to say, “England is the U.K. It can’t leave.” I’m not sure. I’ve only lived in Britain for 20 years. Give me another 5 or 10 decades and I just might understand it.

Talk to me